Jump to content
  • Guest
    Guest

    Sign in to follow this  

    MIFID II – how do we achieve market transparency?

    The MiFID II framework on research cost has set very ambitious targets and requirements to be met by January 2018. If these are met across the spectrum, MiFID II will have successfully increased transparency and substantially reduced conflicts between executions and research within sell side institutions.

     

    The issue however is that while requirements will be met in certain areas, others where it doesn’t make economic sense to implement them may be neglected. This could essentially translate into less market efficiency and transparency for some asset classes.

     

    First, let’s quickly recap on these requirements:

    • Sell side firms must not induce clients to trade bundling research within execution services.
    • Sell side firms are required to review and identify services provided that could be categorised as research and therefore for which payment would be required.
    • Sell side firms need to provide clients unbundled costs of trading, separately identifying and charging execution, research and other advisory services.
    • Buy side firms have to make explicit payments for research, and demonstrate that research contributes to better investment decisions and is therefore not inducement.
    • Investment firms need to provide better reporting to facilitate payments being made for research and to help demonstrate the value that research is providing.

     

    Implications for organisations involve significant changes within different areas such as compliance, operations and technology; and while large institutions have the capacity and resources to scale up, it may not be the case for smaller players covering niche areas.

     

    Ultimately, the question is down to whether buy side clients will bear the additional costs of research instead of the cost of the significant changes. Large Asset Managers such as JP.Morgan AM and Vanguard have already officially announced they will cover the costs, and Aberdeen Asset Management has budgeted £10 million in anticipation. While these large Asset Managers can cover these costs, it’s the smaller managers with niche strategies, focusing on very specific asset classes may not necessarily have the means to actually fund these research costs.

     

    During the past 10 years, the Asset Management industry has been consolidating, and with the emergence and rapid growth of ETF providers, active managers have been under tremendous pressure to decrease their management fees. Equity for instance is a space where active management has particularly been challenged by ETF, and is also an area where sell side research is widely used. Under MIFID II, whether fund managers choose to directly pay research cost from their own account or use a Research Payment Account (RPA) backed by a Commission Sharing Agreement, new cost will put additional strain on margins and/or slow already sluggish new client inflows.

     

    Smaller fund managers may choose not to pay themselves for research, in particular for small cap stocks.  Sell side institutions covering this universe will as a result quit providing research and ultimately, this translates into less information, less investment decision transparency, and more pricing deficiency for small cap stocks.

     

    Let’s reconvene in 2018 and see if MIFID II has successfully increased transparency and substantially reduced conflicts between executions and research within sell side institutions, or not.



    Sign in to follow this  

    Share this  

    Member Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Our picks

    • With Investment Management being increasingly impacted by the growth of FinTech, the industry needs to better understand how people feel about these changes. 
       
      We would appreciate you completing our short survey, and sharing it with your friends and colleagues. We will publish the results in the community in the near future.
       
      Share this       Share this  
       
       
      If you have any issues you can also complete the survey here
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • So with all the discussion ongoing, it is difficult to keep track as to what the timelines are, so I thought that I would pull together an overview of it based on various articles in the media 
       
        • Like
    • In the Deloitte Millennial Report 2018, a clear step change was noted. It stated this particular generation is ‘feeling uneasy about the future. The growth of Industry 4.0 technologies—from robotics and the internet of things to artificial intelligence and cognitive—has altered the nature of work, while political upheavals challenge the established world order.’ 
       
      Against this daunting backdrop however there appears to be quite a clear resolution to these issues and this comes in the shape of mentoring. 
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • Here at AlgoMe we know that one of the best ways to grow our community is through the recommendations of our existing members.
       
      That's why we're offering members the opportunity to win an iPad by simply inviting your friends and colleagues to join the community*.
       
      To be eligible, use the inbuilt invite function, which you can find in the user-bar at the top of the site or app when signed in (), to send personalised invitation emails. When your invitee signs up using the unique link or invitation code they receive, they will appear under your list of successful invites and you will be in with a chance to win.
       
      Each successful invite gives you an additional chance to win.
       
      Please invite people who will be valuable members of the community and have an interest in or experience of Investment Management, Asset Management, FinTech or associated industries.
       
      If you are not already a member, you can register here for free and join in the competition.
       
      Good luck!


       
      iPad model may differ from the image shown
      *Entry is subject to the agreement of the full Terms & Conditions
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • The Investment Association recently gave the industry a boost when it announced the launch of Velocity, its FinTech accelerator.  Designed to identify, develop and accelerate best in class firms with innovative solutions, Velocity will champion and facilitate the wider adoption of technology across the industry.
       
      And AlgoMe will be involved in this too, which is why I’m excited to announce we are now a member organisation of the Investment Association as an official FinTech member and have been named a "company to watch" by Velocity.
       
      Challenging Times
      The Investment Management industry faces major challenges and opportunities from forces such as digital technology, pressure on fees and increased regulation, while at the same time there are widespread changes in the workforce and their expectations.
       
      To date, Investment Management has both been fairly insulated from the challenges posed by agile FinTech competitors, but also distant from the opportunities offered by the new technologies and ways of thinking that such companies bring.
       
      Bringing FinTech closer
      Velocity is a fantastic step towards accelerating the adoption of FinTech. It has received support and endorsements from both inside and outside the industry, including from the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Phillip Hammond, who was enthusiastic about the initiative at a recent City event.
       
      To drive change and innovation, the industry needs to connect across different disciplines and areas of expertise, driving new ways of thinking and fostering cultural change.
       
      Without the benefit of emerging FinTechs and their external expertise, it will be hard for incumbents to harness the benefits of emerging technologies such as Straight Through deal Processing (STP), Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT), and Artificial Intelligence (AI) in areas such as risk and compliance, securities trading and investment decision making.
       
      Our Mission
      AlgoMe's mission is to connect the Investment Management industry and empower professionals to manage their careers. Our new product, AlgoMe Community, is placed to become the hub for the discussion between FinTechs and the companies and professionals in the wider Investment Management ecosystem.
       
      Join AlgoMe Community today
       
      AlgoMe Community - community.algome.com
        • Like
      • 0 replies
  • Categories

  • Related Content

    • Andy Milner
      By Andy Milner
      We have recognised that there is an opportunity to bring market participants together to work collaboratively on shared challenges to assess and solve important issues in financial services. 
       
      TechSprints are two day events that bring together participants from across and outside of financial services to develop technology based ideas or proof of concepts to address specific industry challenges. These events help us to shine a light on issues and expand the discussion and awareness of potential solutions.
       
      AML and Financial Crime International TechSprint | FCA
      WWW.FCA.ORG.UK In May we held a three-day International Anti-Money Laundering and Financial Crime TechSprint. Our fifth and largest TechSprint, the event focused on how new technology can be used to more effectively...  
    • Guest
      By Guest
      Guest blog from Julia Kirkland, Senior Partner at FSTP
      If you don’t know already, which of course you do, the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID) is EU legislation which first came into effect in 2007. It was created to regulate firms providing services to their clients which are linked to ‘financial instruments’, these being shares, bonds, units in collective investment schemes and derivatives. In addition, it covers the venues where those ‘financial instruments’ are traded.
       
      Fast forward 10 years or so and we have an updated version – MiFID II. This includes the revised MiFID and a new Markets in Financial Instruments Regulation (MiFIR). January 3, 2018 is the day MiFID II must be implemented across Europe.
       
      Now we’re on the cusp of this deadline, the thorny and sensitive topic of Knowledge and Competence (K&C) is bubbling up as a major concern across the industry.  We’ve spoken with numerous firms in both the Asset Management and Wealth Management sectors and they have one thing in common; they’re all grappling with the assessment of competence of information providers.
       
      Who is in scope? 
      In Asset Management, this may cover a wide range of roles from sales teams, client services, broker servicing staff to Portfolio Managers (the really sensitive aspect of K&C). Managers may struggle with the fact they must tell a Portfolio Manager of 20 years plus who hasn’t got a formal qualification, they need to be assessed as competent and in a very short timeframe too.
       
      In Wealth, the scope may cover desk assistants, team secretaries and portfolio assistants who may all be in direct contact with clients, giving them information about prices, valuations, charges and providing generic market or sector views. Additionally, research teams who might attend meetings with clients to provide market, sector or stock views on a non-advised basis may fall under this too. Most of the firms we are speaking to are including research teams. Most of the above staff members have never been included in formal K&C Schemes before but this has changed.
       
      What happens in 2018?
      As it stands, information providers not assessed by January 3 will need to be supervised in their activities and oversight of any client interaction must be in place. If you’re not prepared, January 2018 is fast approaching and maybe it’s time to look outside your company for third party support and assistance.
       
      Our guest blogger Julia Kirkland, is Senior Partner, FSTP
      FSTP is a training solution provider with expertise in MiFID II and the company also runs workshops to cover Wealth and Asset Management to meet the ESMA requirements and provides advanced K&C assessments for more seasoned, professional staff.
    • Eva Keogan
      By Eva Keogan
      2018 was always going to be an interesting year. Kicking off with MiFID II, moving to GDPR in the late Spring and of course this Summer brought a surprise World Cup Semi Final and a blistering heat wave (but a still-stagnant Brexit) suffice to say, it’s been a busy time all round.
       
      At AlgoMe we think it’s really important to understand what our wider community is thinking and to get under the skin of the burning issues for 2018.  As result we’ve created The AlgoMe Industry Pulse report which we’ve published today. It has looked into these key issues and themes, from regulation through to Brexit, unearthing some interesting and useful insight. We found optimism and change, along with a level of insecurity too.
       
      What drove these varied responses? Well optimism came in the shape of the 59% who believe Gender Pay Gap Reporting will improve the career progression of women whereas change with learning MiFID II and GDPR is affecting around two thirds of people. Conversely Brexit is creating uncertainty on a number of levels – people want to stay in London, but they’re concerned about their jobs and whether their companies will move away. 30% of those surveyed felt Brexit is a risk to their job security. While 68% believe their companies will stay in the UK, only 54% of individuals said they will definitely stay put versus 27% who are actually considering relocating. When it comes to relocation people chose Dublin, Paris and Amsterdam as the top three choices of European cities to move to. Additionally, regulation will take add to felt insecurity this year with MiFID II impacting 64% of people’s roles and GDPR 60%. Diversity in the workplace is considered important by 64% with 20% remaining neutral and 16% in disagreement, demonstrating there is still a lot of work to be done in both these areas.
       
      We’ve developed 5 key insights which summarise the in depth research:
       
       1. Job confidence pre-Brexit: A workforce in need of reassurance
      Industry and government need to act fast to gain the confidence of the sector as 30% are feeling insecure about Brexit and believe their jobs may be in jeopardy.
       
      2. Will London remain the financial centre of Europe? Best to leave the lights on post-Brexit
      The City is definitely open for business; our industry sector is loyal to London and a majority of workers want to stay here post Brexit.While 27% of respondents expressed they would move as a result of Brexit and 14% of felt strong about this, most people (54%) would not consider moving as a result of Brexit, whereas 68% believe their companies will remain in the UK.  There’s no clear leader in Europe to replace London when it comes to the most desirable places to relocate to and work from; Dublin was the top location (25%), followed by Paris (21%) and Amsterdam (19%).
       
      3. Regulation is a necessary inconvenience:
      Undoubtedly 2018 is a big year for the regulatory calendar and this is having an impact in the short and long term, so we expect temporary upheaval while MiFID II and GDPR are bedded into to working practices
       
      4. Gender Pay Gap – Unwelcome truths for some, seen as much needed by the majority:
      The implication for Gender Pay Gap Reporting is, it will continue to highlight industry inadequacies for some time; transparency and action should expedite change
       
      5. Diversity – More change afoot needed to accommodate a changing workforce:
      Diversity will need to be top of the agenda across the board to effect meaningful progression across the industry
       
      We hope you enjoy this latest report and find the insights valuable to yourselves as professionals, you can download your free copy here.
×

We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. If you continue, we’ll assume you are happy with this. For further information, see our Privacy Policy.