Jump to content
  • Luuk Jacobs
    Luuk Jacobs

    Sign in to follow this  

    Diversity – have we always got it wrong?

    Recently I‘ve been reading a lot of articles on diversity in general, and gender in particular, as well as attending conferences. At the CFA Alpha and Gender Diversity Conference, we were told it will take a further 61 years before we will have achieved gender parity in the workplace.

     

    While slow progress is being made, and the benefits have been scientifically researched and published – I have many more questions and the main one is – why aren’t we making more progress and faster?

     

    Is the focus for diversity in the workplace just a reaction to past high profile lawsuits on sex and race discrimination?  Could this be the reason companies favour the classic ‘command and control’ approach as a diversity strategy (the “do’s and don’ts”, like diversity training, diversity programmes, hiring tests, performance ratings and grievance)?

     

    Are ’Command and Control’ approaches ineffective due to a lack of engagement or motivation of employees/managers in solving the problem?

     

    How can diversity strategies really be effective in the workplace? Is engagement the key to solving the problem, exposing employees and managers to people from the different diversity groups, encouraging social accountability and holding unbiased views?

     

    A Harvard Business Review article sets out several strategies which really do work including recruitment, engagement, contact, social accountability and diversity task forces.

     

    For example, specific recruitment programmes with voluntary participation targeting elements of diversity (gender, race, age) creates cohesion, being part of a positive company message and a feeling of inclusion.

     

    Mentoring of minorities has proven to increase engagement and reduce bias towards them. A mentee becomes a protégé, and is helped and supported in their development and advancement.

     

    Bias can further be reduced through contact i.e. allowing people in different roles and functions to work on projects as equals or let management trainees rotate through departments. It breaks down stereotypes, leading to more equitable hiring and promotion.

     

    Social accountability is a technique in which you tap in the need to look good in the eyes of those around us. It can be achieved through creating transparency whereby for example a company publishes the average performance rating and pay rise by race and gender. Any previous existing differences tend to disappear within a short period.

     

    Diversity task forces discussing and investigating the issues underlying the lack of diversity, while designing the solutions, can have a significant positive impact. The task force members take the solutions back to their departments and manage implementation. As way of an example, a large accounting firm faced an issue in 1992, whereby despite the fact that 50% of the recruited employees were women, hardly any stayed on to become a partner. With a task force in place, the number of female partners increased to 14% in 8 years, by 2015 this had increased to 21% and the current global CEO is female.

     

    So clearly recruitment programs, mentoring, contact, social accountability, diversity task forces are clearly effective but currently not widely employed within businesses and hence improvement of diversity in the workplace will take time. The good news however is that we do know what works, so we just need to apply ourselves to do more of it.



    Sign in to follow this  

    Share this  

    Member Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Our picks

    • Here at AlgoMe we know that one of the best ways to grow our community is through the recommendations of our existing members.
       
      That's why we're offering members the opportunity to win an iPad by simply inviting your friends and colleagues to join the community*.
       
      To be eligible, use the inbuilt invite function, which you can find in the user-bar at the top of the site or app when signed in (), to send personalised invitation emails. When your invitee signs up using the unique link or invitation code they receive, they will appear under your list of successful invites and you will be in with a chance to win.
       
      Each successful invite gives you an additional chance to win.
       
      Please invite people who will be valuable members of the community and have an interest in or experience of Investment Management, Asset Management, FinTech or associated industries.
       
      If you are not already a member, you can register here for free and join in the competition.
       
      Good luck!


       
      iPad model may differ from the image shown
      *Entry is subject to the agreement of the full Terms & Conditions
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • The Investment Association recently gave the industry a boost when it announced the launch of Velocity, its FinTech accelerator.  Designed to identify, develop and accelerate best in class firms with innovative solutions, Velocity will champion and facilitate the wider adoption of technology across the industry.
       
      And AlgoMe will be involved in this too, which is why I’m excited to announce we are now a member organisation of the Investment Association as an official FinTech member and have been named a "company to watch" by Velocity.
       
      Challenging Times
      The Investment Management industry faces major challenges and opportunities from forces such as digital technology, pressure on fees and increased regulation, while at the same time there are widespread changes in the workforce and their expectations.
       
      To date, Investment Management has both been fairly insulated from the challenges posed by agile FinTech competitors, but also distant from the opportunities offered by the new technologies and ways of thinking that such companies bring.
       
      Bringing FinTech closer
      Velocity is a fantastic step towards accelerating the adoption of FinTech. It has received support and endorsements from both inside and outside the industry, including from the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Phillip Hammond, who was enthusiastic about the initiative at a recent City event.
       
      To drive change and innovation, the industry needs to connect across different disciplines and areas of expertise, driving new ways of thinking and fostering cultural change.
       
      Without the benefit of emerging FinTechs and their external expertise, it will be hard for incumbents to harness the benefits of emerging technologies such as Straight Through deal Processing (STP), Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT), and Artificial Intelligence (AI) in areas such as risk and compliance, securities trading and investment decision making.
       
      Our Mission
      AlgoMe's mission is to connect the Investment Management industry and empower professionals to manage their careers. Our new product, AlgoMe Community, is placed to become the hub for the discussion between FinTechs and the companies and professionals in the wider Investment Management ecosystem.
       
      Join AlgoMe Community today
       
      AlgoMe Community - community.algome.com
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • I've been trying to track down details on that statement from the CBI, but I'm not sure they elaborated on what the "unintended consequences" could be - I assume one could be wage inflation due to reduction in the negotiation advantage of the employer.
       
      Whether this is a bad thing is debatable when (by some measures) wage growth has been stagnant in the UK for longer than any time since the Napoleonic wars..
       
      Reality Check: Is pay growth the worst since Napoleon?
      WWW.BBC.CO.UK Reality Check examines the claim that real-wage growth is at its worst since the 18th Century.  
    • How do we solve the the Asset Management industry issues of today and tomorrow?
       
      We think we might just have the answer.
       
      When we created AlgoMe, we set out to empower professionals so they can manage their careers through technology, data and industry insight. With our career management platform, we‘ve delivered this but we know there‘s much more to be done.
       
      The Asset Management industry is in a state of flux. Right now lower fees, higher costs, new technology and increasing regulation, along with changes to the workforce, mean we need access to technology, data and industry insight more than ever before. This is why we‘re taking an exciting step by opening AlgoMe Community, the place that brings the Asset Management industry together to drive open conversation and essential innovation.
       
      AlgoMe Community is a members-only community exclusive to the industry and associated professions.
       
      Membership is free, members are verified and use their own names to create a profile – here are the key benefits:
       
      1. A community for Asset Management
      We have created a standalone space for asset managers meaning discussions and groups are centred around highly relevant areas and get to the heart of issues quickly. We will also be hosting regular events both online and offline to address industry challenges and help our members drive the agenda.
       
      2. Keep your finger on the pulse
      Not sure about Brexit or SMCR? Want to know what the latest research on AI is? The AlgoMe Community gives you direct access to all of these discussions. AlgoMe is working with a number of partner organisations to bring you the latest thought leadership, insights, blog posts and white papers to keep you abreast of the latest trends in Asset Management.
       
      3. Grow Your connections outside of your existing network
      There are a lot of bright minds out there. Over 40,000* people are currently working within the Asset Management industry according to the Investment Association. This number is likely to be 200k+ across Europe with the firms and organisations that make up Asset Management ecosystem. That’s a lot of new connections to make.
       
      4. Grow your personal brand
      Building your personal brand is critical to a successful career. AlgoMe Community gives you a platform to build your credibility and authority among your peers. It’s also easy to start your own blog to get ideas a wider audience and build up a following of other members.
       
      Join AlgoMe Community for free today and connect with the Asset Management industry.
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • Revolt announced it will be offering ETFs to its customers....
      http://igniteseurope.com/c/2090843/247783/revolut_offering_bound_appeal_investors?referrer_module=emailMorningNews&module_order=3&code=WTI5c2FXNHVibWRBWVd4bmIyMWxMbU52YlN3Z01UQTROemN5TURRc0lERXlNVFV4TkRjMk5EWT0
      • 2 replies
  • Categories

  • Similar Content

    • Jonathan Max
      By Jonathan Max
      Earlier this year the Chartered Institute of Personnel Development (CIPD) the professional body for HR and people development in collaboration with Uptimise, a firm which helps organisations attract and leverage neuro diverse talent, produced an excellent guide on Neurodiversity at Work. Simply described the recognition and respecting of different ways of thinking due to autism, dyslexia, ADHD, etc. and consider these various neurological conditions as result of normal variations in the human genome.

      This blog explores the key learnings and how they may be applied to the Financial Services industry. More specifically, we want to look towards Investment Management, and helping raise awareness of the importance and benefits of neurodiversity in the workplace.

      Key points from Neurodiversity at Work
      The business case for diversity in general is now accepted. Organisations now challenge each other with innovation and vie for competitive advantage. As a consequence, there are significant risks of being left behind and one of these is not including people with different ways of thinking or actively leveraging different thinking styles. The Neurodiversity at Work guide points to a clear comparison between man and machine. Unlike a machine, the human brain cannot be determined as ‘fixed’ or ‘broken’; it might just have a different way of operating. 

      The guide focuses on forms of ‘innate neurodivergence’ such as Autism and ADHD; effectively a further pillar of Diversity and Inclusion that seeks to embrace the talents of people who think differently. Neurodiversity is not something binary but rather a range of differences in brain function and behaviours. We need to move away from stereotypical thinking of neurological conditions. The “negative and medicalised language has dominated the lexicon – witness the very terms ‘autism spectrum disorder’ and the double negative in ‘ADHD’. The size of this talent pool should not be underestimated, as the guide reports the overall population of neurominorities is greater than 10%.

      Neurodiversity in action
      According to the report, lessons can be learned from the JPMorgan, EY, Google, Microsoft, SAP, Ford and Amazon who all have, or are developing, neurodiversity initiatives with some more advanced than others.

      JP Morgan
      “Around 80% to 90% of autistic people are unemployed,” says James Mahoney, executive director and head of autism at work at J.P. Morgan. “For us, that’s a talent pool. If you look at areas like technology – there’s a huge shortage of good people with high-level skills. It’s a sector that we know many autistic people excel in.”

      EY
      In 2016 EY launched a neurodiversity program in Philadelphia to hire people on the autism spectrum to serve as Account Support Associates (ASAs). Sam Briefer, one of the first hires under the neurodiversity program said: “We bring something to the table that a lot of people cannot. We are very detail-oriented. We analyse things in a very specific way, and we are good with numbers. And we see things slightly differently, which means we can come up with new and innovative ways of doing things.”

      SAP
      Enterprise software firm SAP has committed 1% of its workforce made up of those on the Autistic spectrum by 2020 – reflecting the percentage of the global population that is Autistic. It’s Autism at Work programme launched in 2013, and the company has transformed the way it recruits and trains staff to be as inclusive as possible. “We had to develop so many processes from scratch because we didn’t want to use standard HR processes,” says Stefanie Nennstiel, senior director of diversity and inclusion at SAP. “Someone with autism would not survive the traditional interview process, for example, so we had to be more creative.” 
       
      Action for Investment Management industry to take
      So, what can the Investment Management industry do to harness this talent and be neurodiversity smart? 

      Clearly there needs to be commitment to neurodiversity from the top of the organisation which then must cascade and be communicated so that this vital group can be integrated into the culture of the firm. Review of workplaces, hiring process and management practices is essential; given the fundamental changes the industry has faced over the last few years, I would hope this would be seen as a further change worth making.
       
      The cost of inaction for Investment Management might be vast, and if you’re pondering when your organisation might adopt a neurodiversity policy, just ask yourself these two questions:
       
      - What will it cost you not to get the most out of your employees in terms of productivity, or to lose talent to more inclusive, attractive employers? 
      - What will it mean for your product innovation to miss out on the ‘diversity of thought’ that neurodiversity can deliver, and that other firms are setting themselves up to benefit from?

      And then you might want to speak to your senior management team or HR, or both.
    • Eva Keogan
      By Eva Keogan
      Facebook is holding its #SheMeansBusiness conference tomorrow so will report back on anything relevant - it's interesting to see a social network take the high ground when it comes to promoting women in business
      Facebook #SheMeansBusiness: Inspiring Women Entrepreneurs
      SHEMEANSBUSINESS.FB.COM Join Facebook in celebrating women entrepreneurs. Go to shemeansbusiness.fb.com to tell your friends about a woman-owned business you know.  
    • Eva Keogan
      By Eva Keogan
      2018 was always going to be an interesting year. Kicking off with MiFID II, moving to GDPR in the late Spring and of course this Summer brought a surprise World Cup Semi Final and a blistering heat wave (but a still-stagnant Brexit) suffice to say, it’s been a busy time all round.
       
      At AlgoMe we think it’s really important to understand what our wider community is thinking and to get under the skin of the burning issues for 2018.  As result we’ve created The AlgoMe Industry Pulse report which we’ve published today. It has looked into these key issues and themes, from regulation through to Brexit, unearthing some interesting and useful insight. We found optimism and change, along with a level of insecurity too.
       
      What drove these varied responses? Well optimism came in the shape of the 59% who believe Gender Pay Gap Reporting will improve the career progression of women whereas change with learning MiFID II and GDPR is affecting around two thirds of people. Conversely Brexit is creating uncertainty on a number of levels – people want to stay in London, but they’re concerned about their jobs and whether their companies will move away. 30% of those surveyed felt Brexit is a risk to their job security. While 68% believe their companies will stay in the UK, only 54% of individuals said they will definitely stay put versus 27% who are actually considering relocating. When it comes to relocation people chose Dublin, Paris and Amsterdam as the top three choices of European cities to move to. Additionally, regulation will take add to felt insecurity this year with MiFID II impacting 64% of people’s roles and GDPR 60%. Diversity in the workplace is considered important by 64% with 20% remaining neutral and 16% in disagreement, demonstrating there is still a lot of work to be done in both these areas.
       
      We’ve developed 5 key insights which summarise the in depth research:
       
       1. Job confidence pre-Brexit: A workforce in need of reassurance
      Industry and government need to act fast to gain the confidence of the sector as 30% are feeling insecure about Brexit and believe their jobs may be in jeopardy.
       
      2. Will London remain the financial centre of Europe? Best to leave the lights on post-Brexit
      The City is definitely open for business; our industry sector is loyal to London and a majority of workers want to stay here post Brexit.While 27% of respondents expressed they would move as a result of Brexit and 14% of felt strong about this, most people (54%) would not consider moving as a result of Brexit, whereas 68% believe their companies will remain in the UK.  There’s no clear leader in Europe to replace London when it comes to the most desirable places to relocate to and work from; Dublin was the top location (25%), followed by Paris (21%) and Amsterdam (19%).
       
      3. Regulation is a necessary inconvenience:
      Undoubtedly 2018 is a big year for the regulatory calendar and this is having an impact in the short and long term, so we expect temporary upheaval while MiFID II and GDPR are bedded into to working practices
       
      4. Gender Pay Gap – Unwelcome truths for some, seen as much needed by the majority:
      The implication for Gender Pay Gap Reporting is, it will continue to highlight industry inadequacies for some time; transparency and action should expedite change
       
      5. Diversity – More change afoot needed to accommodate a changing workforce:
      Diversity will need to be top of the agenda across the board to effect meaningful progression across the industry
       
      We hope you enjoy this latest report and find the insights valuable to yourselves as professionals, you can download your free copy here.
×

We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. If you continue, we’ll assume you are happy with this. For further information, see our Privacy Policy.